Legals And Humans [Round 1]

[Jikanu]

nah, im saying this is how the last vote should go:

The two remaining players (assuming it's down to 1 human, 1 legel) stand up in front of the dead humans, and each posts reasons why they should be believed to be the human. Then, the dead humans vote, and the one with the most votes is allowed to live.

You could rationalize it by saying the dead spirits of the innocent humans came to take vengence on the one who killed them *shrugs*

sorry, didnt see your second post.

Yes, that's basically what im saying, except the votes are reversed and you vote for who you think is innocent after both remaining people make their case.

[Blaaaaaaaah]

But doesn't that kind of ruin the point of the game?

You're supposed to try and convince people that you're innocent throughout the game, and if you have managed to live through till the end, then you shouldn't need to convince -again- because you've already done a good job of it throughout the whole thing.

Dead people should be dead.

[Jikanu]

Ah, but we're in a world of fantasy in this game. Therefore, the souls of the innocent taking a final revenge on the dark souls that killed them should be the ultimate ending.

Besides, isnt it kinda boring to just say "whoo! i made it! i win"? isnt one final showdown kind of more climactic?

[Lirange]

hmm thats an interesting idea
but when its 1v1, there should be enough evidence that everyone already know who is the legal.

and the chances of a 1v1 is also unlikely
maybe if it ever comes to that, and its not obvious who the legal is, we can do that

[Jikanu]

How would it be obvious? i mean, no one would know who killed who. therefore, both competitors have just as much chance.

[Hraesvelg]

So are you suggesting that i should allow legals to vote and show the results?
Or not allow legals to vote and not show the votes.
Theres going to be 16 people in the upcoming game i believe, so it'd be 5v11
And also not to mention the 2 new roles that are going to be in the next game which will be sided with the humans
which of the options should i do?

I prefer the legals voting and counting the votes, then letting everyone know the tally. Because it's waaay too easy to be caught out in a voting lie this way. I should know.

[Lirange]

How would it be obvious? i mean, no one would know who killed who. therefore, both competitors have just as much chance.

Well it was obvious vasu was a legal
everyone voted for him
and if its 1v1, it would make it that much easier
and if you analysis all the posts people make, the voting results, there should be enough evidence to who the legal is. But that is why i said that if it is not obvious who the legal is, i might do that

I prefer the legals voting and counting the votes, then letting everyone know the tally. Because it's waaay too easy to be caught out in a voting lie this way. I should know.

eh, i guess we can try that
see if it would work

[Esen]

I don't really like Jikanu's idea. I don't see a point to it.

As for voting, I think Legels should vote. This is game is pretty much over due to the set up. Why drag on a game that is already over?

I guess I should note that I see this game with a team win and not a individual win. Last person of that team standing = that team's win. Doesn't matter who's dead. Edit: Oh, except if there's less humans than legels cause then the humans can't win anyway if legels can vote.

[Hraesvelg]

Which is traditionally how its done, at least in the live version. This is the first forums version I've done.

[Lirange]

yea, i guess it is a team win, but its kinda like, a fight to the end? even though we know the outcome. But i'm sure some people would like to see who would survive. Unless no one cares, then i will just end the game now.