Which of these weapons would you use?

[pepper22]

My fighter has been stopped at 43 for a while now, and my wife and I have been farming the Giant Goblin Kings. We have been pretty lucky and yesterday found ALL the fighter weapons. 1-handed sword,2-handed and axe. Now, I have enough coin to buy some red eyes and I am upping one of them to +6-9(whenever the red eyes run out). Which one should I use? I have been using an axe, and I wanted to use the axe, but the goblin king axe is only damage, nothing else. The 1-handed/2-handed swords both have great bonuses(+10-20 in ALL stats), while the axe is only +20DEx, nothing else. Also, they all have exactly the same critical, 5%. I tried them all out last night and they all killed in pretty much the same speed, when I get criticals, the axe is a monster, but if skills fail and criticals don't happen, the axe is nothing special. I was thinking the 1-hander might be nice as it has 5%crit rate and adds 20STR to boot, but I just don't know. I mainly solo or play with my wife's cleric, so killing speed is more inportant than a shield,but I found wearing the shield greatly lowered the stones and pots I am spamming. What do you guys/gals think??