Should I feel guilty? - Page 5

Knil · 04-07-2008, 04:45 PM

hahaha, i spent so long writing that that you wrote your decision XD

**Spirit** · 04-07-2008, 05:52 PM

Originally Posted by Manzcar

I am resloved and I don't feel guilty. This has started a debate that has gone longer and harder than I actually expected.

A game is a game.

OHH and to help with those that disagree with me not feeling guilty, when I get to a level that I no longe need or want the axe, I am going to give it away with the stipulation that the axe can never be sold but must be handed down from Fighter to Fighter for the rest of the game.

Now that makes it interesting.

Yes, but it such a good debate and I am enjoying it so much.

**Loveless** · 04-07-2008, 06:21 PM

Just make sure it does get handed down to the right 'generations'.

**Manzcar** · 04-07-2008, 06:37 PM

Originally Posted by Spirit

Yes, but it such a good debate and I am enjoying it so much.

Ohh there's no need to stop the debate. My whole point of the post was to say hey look what I found.

so if you think I should feel guilty tell me why. If you don't tell me why.

Okay now talk amoungst yourselves.

Ohh Loki I really wasn't kidding about the loan thing. Let me know.

mof · 04-07-2008, 06:59 PM

I gotta say that was a good read indeed.

I don't want to respond to every single post, so I'll say some here and respond to other other comments directed at me. I personally would feel guilty for keeping the weapon - that's just me though.

Some people said it's just a game and it's the seller's fault and you can do what you want - yes that's true. But since it IS a game, people can ks and loot steal and do all those things people rant about, which apparently, makes them jerks.

"Oh look! That player is 10 years old... I think I'm gonna do the 'I'll enhance your weapon scam' on them... They'll get scammed sooner or later for sure, why not learn the lesson early." - Sure you can do that... OR tell them and teach them what scams they need to be aware of.

If I sold a +9 weap for 1s by accident the first thing I'd do is check my pms to see if anyone whispered me to give me my weapon back. Whether they give me my weapon back or not doesn't change the fact that I would have learned my lesson already! So if I'd appreciate this gesture, why would I not return this gesture to others? Because I'm selfish? Well sure I'm selfish to a certain extent... That's where you draw the line.

So I either would try to return the weapon and not feel guilty, or keep it and feel guilty (not sure how much).

edit: On a separate note, can I use your new xbow? XD

**Enraya** · 04-08-2008, 08:21 AM

I'm not finished debating~

I've got another analogy! o:

Person A is going to die tomorrow, you know it. Does it make it right to kill him today? No. But you know very well that if you do not kill person A, person B will kill person A. If not B, then C.

See, if I slit A's throat, I have a choice. I can let him bleed to death, or I can press a finger to his would and decide to bandage it up. If I bandage it up, there'll be a scar to person A, a reminder to never let his guard down. But if I don't make the decision to slit him, person B, C, Z is going to come hunt them down with a machete and kill A.

I would rather take it myself, because I know I have a choice of giving it back to them or not. How would I know if B - Z will think the way that I do? How do I know they're not going to steal it? I don't. So the best choice for both me and person A is for me to slit his throat, and I'll decide whether to rush him to the hospital or let him bleed.

mof · 04-08-2008, 03:35 PM

Aye I know what you're saying lightning - after shivering at that gruesome example... what movies have you been watching lately? ^^

Ulrike · 04-08-2008, 07:52 PM

no you shouldn't feel guilty.

This coming from someone who accidentally sold a godly lv50 2h +9 sword by mis-pricing

le sigh >>

**Manzcar** · 04-08-2008, 08:02 PM

I thought this would be an interesting topic of discussion, but I never thought it would cause this kind of debate.

Or very scary "for instances" that have been put out there.

I am keeping the axe, I am going to use the axe, and then I will give the axe away to a deserving person of my choice.

**Lady-Loki** · 04-08-2008, 11:31 PM

Originally Posted by Manzcar

Ohh Loki I really wasn't kidding about the loan thing. Let me know.

Awww. Thanks, I'm a sword kinda gal but I just might take you up on that offer if I decide to work my fighter and you are not leveled up enough yet.

But truth be told, you will probably pass my fighter in level since mine is an alt - my main is a cleric.