Legals and Humans Game Mechanics Discussion

[Hessah]

I think the Russian Roulette would only work if we had just as many players as this round (like 12+)..

Otherwise Humans usually need at least 2 days to get some lead, and if you've got humans randomly dying too it would seriously disadvantage them...

but if most people wanna give it a go then I guess we can try..

So what does it mean that the bomb can side with human or legal? They get to choose? Or just means it has no side? It doesn't win?

[Lirange]

@blahs It may also be safer to not choose to take your turn first. Chances are the last person will not be the person who gets killed most of the time. Advantages of you going first is that your have a higher chance of living but the advantage of waiting is that 4-5 other people has a chance to die before you. It really depends on the person.

@Hessah Yeah, there do need to be a big game. How bout making it so that it can only be activated after day 2 or something? And Teva chooses which side gets the bomb. Or do you guys think it should just be human sided only?

[Blaaaaaaaah]

I liked the idea that bomb was human sided.

[Lirange]

I was thinking the bomb will only hurt the legal but then I remember you can vote for it and be killed. I'll change it backxD

[Hessah]

Oh I'm happy that bomb can be either side.. I just wanted to clarify what you meant.. keke

[Lirange]

Yeah, but the thing is, if it's sided with legals then only humans can get hurt. If sided with humans, either side can get hurt.

Also about blahs changed robo thing, so robo will be sided with legals but legals will not know who robo is and vise versa? And robo wins when legals win? Eh, I'm not so into that. I kinda like the way is now. xD That's the only legal role=/

Also people, please suggest more legal roles. We currently only have one.

[Hessah]

I think legals have enough power and they don't really need more roles... the fact that they know who each other are gives them a much bigger advantage...

Also.. should all human roles be performed at night? to be in line with Robo's block?

[Ralath]

I think Bomb should be able to kill both Human and Legel.

[Lirange]

I think legals have enough power and they don't really need more roles... the fact that they know who each other are gives them a much bigger advantage...

Also.. should all human roles be performed at night? to be in line with Robo's block?

Robo's block last for 24 hours.
Also, more roles won't give legals more power, just more diversity. Currently if you decide you want a legal to have a role, they can only have robo. Also, the updated robo cannot block a person twice in a row.

[Blaaaaaaaah]

Yeah, but the thing is, if it's sided with legals then only humans can get hurt. If sided with humans, either side can get hurt.

Also about blahs changed robo thing, so robo will be sided with legals but legals will not know who robo is and vise versa? And robo wins when legals win? Eh, I'm not so into that. I kinda like the way is now. xD That's the only legal role=/

I don't think we need any more Legal roles. We would need a lot more participants to have any more Legal roles, at least. Like Hessah said, Legals are pretty powerful already. The fact that Humans don't win every round shows this.

I suggest for Robo and Legals to be anonymous to each other because Humans and Julia/Robin/Myzen/Shutian etc are anonymous to each other. If humans don't know other human helper roles, then maybe legals shouldn't know who else is out there to help them.

When it comes to unknown roles, and Robo is part of it, Legals always have extra knowledge because they already know what one of the unknown roles are, while humans don't. I think it'll just be more fun that way and make it a little harder for legals.

I think Bomb should be able to kill both Human and Legel.

Ditto.