[Discussion] Guess the Picture!

[Blaaaaaaaah]

To me, if you had answered enhanced bow, then you would have been right. It is an enhanced bow. But the answer +6 bow is wrong because it isn't a +6 bow.

Yes, it is exactly that.. I couldn't give you the point because +6 enhanced glow is wrong. It was like the example I gave earlier, where Triumph guessed werebear claw and Ralath guessed werebear. If Triumph also had the first guess (though in his case, he answered second), I would have had to given to Ralath too because werebear claw is not right as it is werebear chest.

Sorry about that. I cannot exactly change the rules all the time when a new situation pops up because it will make the game more and more confusing (unless it's something really wrong), though I will take this situation into account if this game ever happens again in the future~ Perhaps I will devise a new point system or something. Always welcome for feedback.

[Dynamics]

Can't figure out the latest picture, the one with the grey bar.. I think I've had enough guessesand I'm gonna rep whoever ends up getting it haha.

[Lady-Loki]

Well, I understand these things are not really open for discussion, but . . .

IMHO, the image Booyah guessed on was a "General" image and not a "Challenge" image so a response that contained the correct "general" answer should have been accepted. Had it been a "Challenge" image then the specific enhancement level could have been required.

Just my opinion.

Edit #1 - ALSO: Any chance all images can be posted in the OP for ease or locating?

Edit #2 - ALSO: Any chance the full image can be posted after the correct guess is acknowledged? I can see some, but I look at that Power Scroll image and have a hard time getting that picture to form.

[Dynamics]

Well, I understand these things are not really open for discussion, but . . .

IMHO, the image Booyah guessed on was a "General" image and not a "Challenge" image so a response that contained the correct "general" answer should have been accepted. Had it been a "Challenge" image then the specific enhancement level could have been required.

Just my opinion.

Edit #1 - ALSO: Any chance all images can be posted in the OP for ease or locating?

Edit #2 - ALSO: Any chance the full image can be posted after the correct guess is acknowledged? I can see some, but I look at that Power Scroll image and have a hard time getting that picture to form.

Hm I might be too late for me to chime in but this is how I saw the situation.




Booyah's guess is yellow, the answer is red, the general area is purple. Obviously getting the answer perfectly correct is fine (the red area). A general guess would hit the red area just fine too since they overlap, but being too specific made him miss the red mark.

It does suck that he didn't get the points, but that's the risk you take when you have a guess. A couple people by now have had close guesses, or hit the general area but have missed the mark and subsequently opened eyes for every other guesser out there. It's just how a guessing game with a hint system like this is going to work. It can work for or against you.

I think for the 1 point guesses people should try to keep a general guess. Like with the elderine fence guess, I was going to be specific and say "avon's fence" but realised there are several fences in elderine that have a similar pattern. So I just went with the elderine fence guess, which I was hoping would be enough to hit the mark.

[Hessah]

Is it funny to see all the guess's we've got when u know wat the answer is? LOL!

[Blaaaaaaaah]

Yes, especially when I put up Wishis and the guesses were fire nix and dog from the santa slay. Wishis won't be happy, Hyper and Dyna!

[Hyper]

Really sorry, booyah... >.<

Yes, especially when I put up Wishis and the guesses were fire nix and dog from the santa slay. Wishis won't be happy, Hyper and Dyna!

Hey, what can someone expect when they look like that?!

[Dynamics]

Though I have nothing to say in my defence, I will say this for Ralath:

He didn't guess wishis randomly, thinking of the dogs from the santa slay and a fire nix fused together gave him inspiration. I think Hyper and I deserve points for that.

[Andromeda]

Not like it matters now but dont I have 5 points and not 3 xD