I voted the first one because the second one's background looks a bit messy, and I prefer coloured signatures rather than black and white.
It would be nice if you added a bit more to your first signature though. Maybe an actual pic of the char you used in your pic. It took me a while to realise the white shape was your cleric~ A thinner border might be good too!
But it's cool anyway! What did you use if you didn't have photoshop then? D: I can't live without my photoshop. >________________<"
__________________
=)

|